Money Stories 

Toolkit: PI2-MS
Participatory Investing toolkit

REFLECTING ON MONEY STORIES & RESOURCE SCENARIOS

Reflecting on Money Stories and Resource Scenarios

Introduction

REFLECTING ON MONEY STORIES & RESOURCE SCENARIOS

Before groups can meaningfully share power over resources, they must first understand the often-unspoken stories they carry about money itself. These stories shape how we interpret risk, responsibility, urgency, fairness, and worth. They influence whether we default toward control or collaboration, protection or possibility.

In participatory investing and other community-rooted finance approaches, money is not neutral. Financial decision-making is a root determinant of health, and the meanings we assign to money directly affect whose knowledge is trusted, whose needs are prioritized, and how flexible or rigid systems become when conditions change. This reflection invites participants to examine how their personal and institutional money stories were formed, how they show up in collective decision-making, and how they may reinforce patterns of scarcity or abundance in shared work.

The following prompts can be explored as individual journal prompts or facilitation tools for groups initiating work on shared governance of resources.

Part One

Journaling to Explore Your Money Stories:

Relationships with money are rarely taught explicitly. Rather, most of our experiences with money are absorbed through family dynamics, institutional rules, crisis moments, and cultural narratives about success, failure, and security. This reflection is an opportunity to surface those influences and notice how they continue to shape our current individual and professional choices.
Reflect on the following prompts individually. If you are a trainer or facilitator for a group, invite groups to pair share or discuss in small groups after individual reflection.

What messages did you learn about money growing up?
fear, pride, shame, freedom, security
Debrief with the group after the reflection and in groups, small pair shares. Invite participants to share their money stories along with insights around the following debrief questions:

What surprised you?

What common themes arose?

How does this discussion shape your view of healthcare resourcing?

Exercise - part two

Scarcity / Abundance Exercise

The following exercise explores scarcity and abundance and builds directly on the money stories reflection.  This exercise invites participants to notice not just what decisions they make, but how they make them, what assumptions feel urgent, and what tradeoffs become visible or invisible under different conditions. The reflection space to follow invites participants to pay attention to the calculations, emotions, and patterns emerging through engaging with the exercise.

AIM:

To help explore how conditions shape decisions, risk tolerance, and innovation related to resourcing community health initiatives.

Scenario

You are a group of community stakeholders who have made a $10M ask for community health initiatives. The larger group is split in two and given two assignments to discuss. Group A asked for $10M to support a holistic health initiative and ultimately received $1M from the funder. Group B asked for $10M, also to support a holistic health initiative and received $100M from the funder. Each group engages in a strategy dialogue around what the funder is allocating to the initiative. What will each group decide to do with the funding?
Group A

Asked for $10M
Received $1M

Group B

Asked for $10M
Received $100M

Facilitation Prompts

The facilitator brings the two groups back together and asks each to present their scenario (the ask and the funding decision) as well as what their group decided to do with the new funding awards. The facilitator then engages the group in a discussion about what came up in their respective group dialogues when the funding amount was different from the ask. Prompts to engage the group in their process and approach can focus on:
What emotions come up?
Bring in insights from Nature of Trust regarding what nature tells us about risk-taking in times of scarcity and times of abundance

section three

Lessons from nature

Insights from nature remind us that context powerfully shapes behavior. In nature, moderate comfort often reinforces the status quo, while extreme scarcity and conditions of abundance can unlock risk-taking, experimentation, and cooperation. Trust emerges because conditions make cooperation viable and adaptive. Participatory investing asks us to intentionally design those conditions.

As participants complete the scenario exercise, invite the group to notice how resource conditions influence behavior, and facilitate or inhibit experimentation with structures that support shared risk, learning, and long-term stewardship. Invite the group to consider how establishing conditions that foster risk-taking and trust-building can be critical for the success of initiatlves aiming to shift power toward community-led resourcing decisions. When tension arises around risk, timelines, or control, returning to the underlying money stories can open space for dialogue, repair, and more durable collaboration.

section Four

DEBRIEF QUESTIONS

Individual Reflection
When did I feel aligned or disoriented in the process?
[answer or prompt goes here]
Group Debrief
What were the biggest shifts in thinking during this process?

Learn how Shift Health Accelerator Can Help